Using Georgia to Target Russia
By Stephen Lendman
August 13, 2008
After the Soviet Union's 1991 dissolution, Georgia's
South Ossetia province broke away and declared its
independence. So far it remains undiplomatically
recognized by UN member states. It's been
traditionally allied with Russia and wishes to reunite
with Northern Ossetes in the North Ossetia-Alania
Russian republic. Nothing so far is in prospect, but
Russia appears receptive to the idea. And for Abkhazia
as well, Georgia's other breakaway province. The
conflict also has implications for Transdniestria, the
small independent Russian-majority part of Moldova
bordering Ukraine, and for Nagorno-Karabakh in
Azerbaijan.
Tensions arose and conflict broke out in late 1991. It
resulted in a 1992 ceasefire to avoid a major
confrontation with Russia, but things remained
unsettled. Moscow maintains a military presence in the
province as well as in Abkhazia and exerts
considerable political and economic influence.
Throughout the 1990s, intermittent conflict erupted
but nothing on the order of early August 7 when
Georgia acted with aggression against the S. Ossetian
capital, Tskninvali.
Russiatoday.com reported the early timeline:
- at 22:50 GMT, Tskhinvali reported heavy shelling;
- 22:00 GMT - TASS news agency reported intensive
Georgian firing on the capital's residential areas;
- 21:27 GMT - Russia's Vesti television reported that
S. Ossetia's military downed a Georgian attack plane;
- 21:25 GMT - Georgia announced plans to withdraw
half its Iraq forces because of the conflict;
- 21:22 GMT - S. Ossetia claimed to be in control of
Tskhinvali, but Georgian forces attempted to retake
the city;
- 20:36 GMT - The UN Security Council began
closed-door discussions on the conflict - initiated by
Georgia and the second in 24 hours;
- 20:25 GMT - Georgia asked the US to pressure Russia
to "stop (its) armed aggression;"
- 19:08 GMT - Russian President Dmitry Medvedev said
"Russia is taking adequate military and political
measures" to end the violence;
- 18:56 GMT - S. Ossetia's government said it
controls Tskhinvali, but fighting in one city district
continued;
- 17:35 GMT - Georgian President Saakashvili claimed
that Georgia controlled Tskhinvali and most S.
Ossetian villages and regions;
- 17:20 GMT - S. Ossetian leader Kokoity asked the
world community to stop Georgia's "genocide" and
recognize the territory's independence; he claimed
1400 deaths in the fighting;
- 16:46 GMT - thousands of S. Osettians fled the
fighting;
- 16:14 GMT - Russia's Air Force denied bombing a
Georgian military base;
- 14:23 GMT - reports from Tskhinvali indicated mass
fires in the city;
- 13:25 GMT - Russia's Defence Ministry accused
Georgian troops of shooting peacekeepers and civilians
and denying them medical help;
- 13:16 GMT - Saakashvili accused Russia of waging
war and asked for US support;
- 12:55 GMT - Russian Foreign Minister Lavrov accused
Georgia of ethnic cleansing Ossetian villages;
- 12:04 GMT - Russia's Defence Ministry said it sent
peacekeeping reinforcements to S. Ossetia;
- 11:25 GMT - reports indicated that Tskhinvali was
completely destroyed;
- 10:33 GMT - Georgia announced a three-hour
ceasefire to let civilians evacuate the conflict zone;
- 9:36 GMT - Russia's Parliament cited Georgia's
aggression as a "serious reason" to recognize S.
Ossetian independence;
- 8:18 GMT - firefights spread to Tskhinvali streets;
- 6:51 GMT - the UN Security Council failed to
approve a Russia-sponsored ceasefire call; fighting
intensified;
- 5:01 GMT - S. Ossetia sought Russian protection and
help to stop the fighting; and
- 4:13 GMT - Georgian troops resumed attacking
Tskhinvali in a continued act of aggression; things
remained unsettled; fighting continued and at times
with ferocity.
On August 8, The New York Times reported that Georgia
officials "accused Russia (on August 5) of violating
the country's airspace and firing a guided
missile...." Russia denied the charge, called it
baseless, and said no Russian planes were in the area
either August 4 or 5th. Georgia, on the other hand,
said they were as a "provocation aimed only" to
disrupt Georgia's peace and "change the political
course of the country."
Earlier in March, Georgia accused Russia of launching
missile attacks on Georgian villages in the volatile
Kodori Gorge. Relations deteriorated markedly last
year after Georgia arrested and deported four Russian
Army officers, accusing them of spying. Moscow
recalled its ambassador, cut air, sea and postal
links, and deported several thousand Georgians in
response. These events and others led up to the
present conflict with considerable suspicions about
what's behind them. The New York Times reported
(August 10) that conflict had been brewing for years
but suggested Russia is at fault:
- emboldened by its Checknya successes;
- the Kremlin's loathing of President Saakashvili -
personally and politically;
- tensions over Washington's ties with him -
providing political, economic and especially military
support, including a total overhaul of its forces
complete with large stockpiles state-of-the-art
weapons and munitions as well as training to use them;
- Saakashvili's alliance with the Bush administration
in Iraq; and
- President Putin granting citizenship and passports
to most S. Ossetian and Abkhazian adults.
Unmentioned by The Times are:
- reasons behind the growing tensions between
Washington and Moscow;
- the Bush administration's unilateral abandonment of
the 1972 Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty (ABM);
- its continued provocations around the world,
including in areas sensitive to Russia;
- its massive military buildup;
- its advocacy for preventive, preemptive and
"proactive" wars with first-strike nuclear weapons;
- NATO's role in serving America's imperial
interests;
- enlarging it with new member states, including
former Soviet republics;
- encircling Russia with US military bases;
- situating them in former Soviet republics and
regional states;
- the strategic importance of Georgia for the
Anglo-American Caspian oil pipeline; its extension
from Baku, Azerbaijan (on the Caspian) through Georgia
(well south of S. Ossetia), bypassing Russia and Iran,
and across Turkey to its port city of Ceyhan - the
so-called BTC pipeline for around one million barrels
of oil daily, adjacent to the South Causasus (gas)
Pipeline with a capacity of about 16 billion cubic
meters annually;
- the regional stakes involved: Washington and Russia
vying to control Eurasia's vast oil and gas reserves;
- Israel's role in the region; its interest in the
BTC pipline; its negotiations with Georgia, Turkey,
Turkmenistan and Azarbaijan to have it reach its
Ashkelon oil terminal and Red Sea Eilat port; its
selling Georgia state-of-the-art weapons, electronic
warfare systems and intelligence; its use of military
advisors to train Georgian forces in commando, air,
sea, armored and artillery tactics as well as
instruction on military intelligence and security;
- its refusal to freeze its Georgian military
alliance; the dubious reliability of Haaretz citing an
AP August 7 report that "Israel has decided to halt
all sales of military equipment to Georgia because of
(Russia's) objections....to give Israel leverage with
Moscow....not to ship arms and equipment to Iran" such
as sophisticated S-300 air defense missiles; the
Israeli Foreign Ministry refusing comment on an arms
freeze and Georgian Cabinet minister Temur
Yakobashvili saying "There has been no decision by
Israel to stop selling (us) weapons;"
- believe it, and here's what Haaretz says Israel
supplies: high-tech infantry weapons, artillery
systems electronics, and upgrades for Soviet-designed
Su-25 ground attack jets as well as Israeli generals
advising Georgia's military; Israel also sells Hermes
450 UAV spy drones according to Russiatoday.com;
according to some sources, it's a virtual gold mine
for Israeli defense contractors, but Haaretz reports
it's much less at around $200 million a year - well
below American and French sales;
- on August 10, the Israeli ynetnews.com highlighted
"The Israeli Connection" and reported "Israeli
companies have been helping (the) Georgian army
(prepare) for war against Russia through arms deals,
training of infantry and security advice;" it was
helped by Georgian citizens "who immigrated to Israel
and became businesspeople," and the fact that
Georgia's Defense Minister, Davit Kezerashvili, "is a
former Israeli fluent in Hebrew (whose) door was
always open to the Israelis who came and offered his
country arms;" deals went through "fast" and included
"remote-piloted (Elbit System) vehicles (RPVs),
automatic turrets for armed vehicles, antiaircraft
systems, communications systems, shells and rockets;"
- Russia's anger over Georgia and Ukraine seeking
NATO membership and Washington's pressuring other
members to admit them;
- the planned installation of "missile defense" radar
in the region - in Poland, Czechoslovakia and
potentially other sensitive areas, all targeting
Russia, China, and Iran;
- its provoking Russia to retarget nuclear missiles
at planned "radar" locations; and
- targeting Russia for dissolution (as the US's main
world rival), diffuse its power, control Eurasia,
including the country's immense resources on the
world's by far largest land mass.
The New Great Game
What's at stake is what former National Security
advisor Zbigniew Brzezinski described in his 1997 book
"The Grand Chessboard." He called Eurasia the "center
of world power extending from Germany and Poland in
the East through Russia and China to the Pacific and
including the Middle East and the Indian
subcontinent." He continued: "The most immediate (US)
task is to make certain that no state or combination
of states gains the capacity to expel the United
States from Eurasia or even to diminish significantly
its decisive arbitration role." Dominating that part
of the world and its vast energy and other resources
is Washington's goal with NATO and Israel its
principal tools to do it:
- in the Middle East with its two-thirds of the
world's proved oil reserves (about 675 billion
barrels); and
- the Caspian basin with an estimated 270 billion
barrels of oil plus one-eighth of the world's natural
gas reserves.
"New World Order" strategy aims to secure them.
Russia, China, and Iran have other plans. India allies
with both sides. Former Warsaw Pact and Soviet
republics split this way:
- NATO members include the Czech Republic, Slovakia,
Hungary, Poland, Romania, Albania, Bulgaria, Estonia,
Latvia, and Lithuania;
- Georgia and Ukraine seek membership; while
- Armenia, Azerbaijan, Belarus, Kazahkstan, Moldova,
Tajikistan, Uzbekistan, Turkmenistan, and Kyrgystan
ally with Russia.
Georgia now occupies center stage, so first some
background about a nation Michel Chossudovsky calls
"an outpost of US and NATO forces" located
strategically on Russia's border "within proximity of
the Middle East Central Asian war theater." Breakaway
S. Ossetia and Abkhazia, though small in size, are
very much players in what's unfolding with potential
to have it develop into something much bigger than a
short-lived regional conflict.
In 2003 with considerable CIA help, Georgia's
President Saskashvili came to power in the so-called
bloodless "Rose Revolution." Georgia held
parliamentary elections on November 2. International
observers called them unfair. Sackashvili claimed he
won. He and the united opposition called for protests
and civil disobedience. They began in mid-November in
the capital Tbilisi, then spread throughout the
country. They peaked on November 22, the scheduled
opening day for parliament. Instead, Saakashvili-led
supporters placed "roses" in the barrels of soldiers'
rifles, seized the parliament building, interrupted
President Eduard Shevardnadze's speech, and forced him
to escape for his safety.
Saakashvili declared a state of emergency, mobilized
troops and police, met with Shevardnadze and Zurab
Zhvania (the former parliament speaker and choice for
new prime minister), and apparently convinced the
Georgian president to resign. Celebrations erupted. A
temporary president was installed. Georgia's Supreme
Court annulled the elections, and on January 4, 2004,
Saakashvili was elected and inaugurated president on
January 25. New parliamentary elections were held on
March 28. Saakashvili's supporters used heavy-handed
tactics to gain full control, but behind the scenes
Washington is fully in charge. It pulls the strings on
its new man in Georgia and stepped up tensions with
Russia for control of the strategically important
southern Causasus region.
On January 5, 2008, Saakashvili won reelection for a
second term in a process his opponents called rigged.
Given how he first gained power and the CIA's role in
it, those accusations have considerable merit.
After the outbreak of the current crisis, Russia's
NATO envoy, Dmitry Rogozin, accused the Alliance of
"encourag(ing) Georgia to attack S. Ossetia and called
it "an undisguised aggression accompanied by a mass
propaganda war." Russia's Foreign Minister, Sergey
Lavrov, called attention to Georgia's "massive arms
purchasing....during several years" and its use of
"foreign specialists" to train "Georgian special
troops."
In his August 10 article titled - "War in the
Causasus: Towards a Broader Russia-US Military
Confrontation?" - Chossudovsky notes how "attacks were
timed to coincide with the Olympics largely with a
view to avoiding frontpage media coverage" and to let
saturation Beijing reports serve as distraction.
Now after days of fighting, headlines cite 2000 or
more deaths (largely civilians), huge amounts of
destruction, Tskhinvali in ruins, and many thousands
of refugees seeking safe havens. Accounts of Georgian
atrocities have also surfaced, and according to
Chossudovsky they're part of a planned "humanitarian
disaster (against civilian targets) rather than (an
impossible to achieve) military victory" against a
nation as powerful as Russia. Had Georgia sought
control, a far different operation would have unfolded
"with Special Forces occupying key public buildings,
communications networks and provincial institutions."
So why did this happen, and what can Washington hope
to gain when it's bogged down in two wars, threatening
another against Iran, and thoroughly in disrepute as a
result? It's part of a broader "Great Game" strategy
pitting the world's two great powers against each
other for control of this vital part of the world.
Bush administration plans may come down to this -
portray Russia as another Serbia, isolate the country,
and equate Putin and/or Medvedev with Milosevic and
hope for all the political advantage it can gain. "The
war on Southern Ossetia," according to Chossudovsky,
"was not meant to be won, leading to the restoration
of Georgian sovereignty over (the province). It was
intended to destabilize the region while triggering a
US-NATO confrontation with Russia."
Georgia is its proxy. Its attack on S. Ossetia is a
made-in-Washington operation. But not according to
George Bush (on August 10) who "strongly condemned
(Russia's) disproportionate response," and Dick Cheney
(on the same day) saying its military "aggression must
not go unanswered, and that its continuation would
have serious consequences for its relations with the
United States, as well as the broader international
community." An EU statement agreed. It expressed its
"commitment to the sovereignty and the territorial
integrity of Georgia" and pretty much accused Russia
of aggression.
Russia's response and capabilities are unsurprising.
It counterattacked in force, battered Georgian troops,
inflicted damage at will, reportedly overran the Gori
military base in Senaki, moved south into Georgia
proper, and largely attacked military targets with
great effect. It also wants an emergency meeting with
NATO and issued an ultimatum for Georgian troops to
disarm in the Zugdidi District along the Abkhazia -
Georgia border. For its part, Georgian officials said
Russia's "wide-scale assault (is) aimed at
overthrowing the government."
On August 10, the London Guardian reported that the
Caucasus conflict "spread to Georgia's second
breakaway province of Abkhazia, where separatist
rebels and the Russian air force launched an all-out
attack on Georgian forces." Abkhazia's leader, Sergei
Bagapsh, said "around 1000 Abkhaz troops" engaged in a
major "military operation" to force Georgian forces
out of the strategic Kodori gorge. Russian army
spokesman, Anatoly Nogovitsyn, told Interfax: "We do
not intend to take the initiative in escalating the
conflict in this region. We are primarily interested
in" stabilizing Abkhazia.
On August 12, AP reported that "Russian President
Dmitri Medvedev ordered a halt to military action in
Georgia (today), saying it had punished (the country)
and brought security for civilians and Russian
peacekeepers." Nonetheless, reports are that fighting
continues, and Medvedev ordered his military to quell
"any emerging hotbeds of resistance or any aggressive
actions...." Foreign Minister Lavrov added that Moscow
won't talk to Saakashvili and said he'd "better go."
The latest AP August 13 report is that Georgian
officials claim Russian tanks "seized a (Georgian)
military base (and) also held onto ground in western
Georgia, maintaining control of the town of Zugdidi."
For its part, "Russia accused Georgia of killing more
than 2000 people, mostly civilians, in South Ossetia."
Witnesses confirmed that hundreds had died there, and
expectations are that the death toll will rise
"because large areas of Georgia (are) too dangerous
for journalists to enter (to assess) the true scope of
the damage."
On the Attack - The Corporate Media React
Despite the Olympic distraction, the dominant media
jumped on this story and are unsurprisingly one-sided
in their reports. On August 11, a New York Times
editorial headlined "Russia's War of Ambition" in
which it lamented that Saakashvili "foolishly and
tragically baited the Russians - or even more
foolishly fell into Moscow's trap...." It accused the
Kremlin of "bull(ying) and blackmail(ing) its
neighbors and its own people." It stated "There is no
imaginable excuse for (invading) Georgia" and defended
"Saakashvili's 'democratically elected' government."
It accused Vladimir Putin of "shoulder(ing) aside
(Medvedev) to run the war (and) appears determined to
reimpose by force and intimidation as much of the old
Soviet sphere of influence as he can get away with."
The US and its European allies "must tell Mr. Putin in
the clearest possible terms that such aggression will
not be tolerated." They'll also "need to take a hard
look at their relationship with Russia going
forward....Russia needs to behave responsibly. And the
United States and Europe must make clear that anything
less is unacceptable."
The Los Angeles Times' op-ed writer Max Boot (noted
for his hard-right views) was just as one-sided in
referring to the "Red Army" and saying the West must
"Stand up to Russia." It must protect Saakhashvili and
prevent Moscow from "replac(ing) him with a
pro-Kremlin stooge." Its leaders must "stand together
and make clear that this aggression will not stand."
He called Russia's "excuses" for its
"aggression....particularly creepy" and said they
mirrored Hitler's when he "swallow(ed) Czechoslovakia
and Poland." He added that "the lesson" of the 1930s
must be heeded because the "cost of inaction" is too
high.
David Clark in the London Guardian was also hostile in
his op-ed headlined "The west can no longer stand idle
while the Russian bully wreaks havoc." He described
"Russian policy (as) uniquely destructive in
generating instability and political division in the
Caucasus" and excused Saakhashvili for his actions. He
referred to "Georgia's role in maintaining the only
east-west pipeline route free of Russia's monopolistic
grip...." He called Georgia's security concerns "real,
and Russia is the cause." David Clark is a former
government adviser and now chairman of the pro-West
Russia Foundation.
The Wall Street covers this story daily in news
reports and commentaries. On August 11, it gave
Saakashvili a half page for his op-ed headlined "The
War in Georgia Is a War for the West," and he didn't
mince words. He accused Russia of "waging (all-out)
war on my country (that's) not of Georgia's making
(nor its) choice. The Kremlin designed this
war....(it's) a war about (Georgia's) independence and
future (and) about the future of freedom in Europe."
On August 12, writers Gary Schmitt and Mauro De
Lorenzo headlined "How the West Can Stand up to
Russia," and they were just as hostile. They accused
Moscow of "cutthroat politics....at home and abroad"
and asked "What can the West do?" First they urge
"rush(ing) military and medical supplies to Tbilisi
(and) Washington should lead." It should then tell
Moscow that the West has a "greater capacity to
sustain a new Cold War (and aim) to put Mr. Putin and
Dmitry Medvedev on their back foot diplomatically."
Then on to the larger issue of "break(ing) Russia's
"stranglehold on Europe's energy supplies" and one
other thing - building a "strong, prosperous and fully
independent Georgia (heading for) NATO and EU
membership" allied against Russia.
The Journal's same day editorial headlined "Vladimir
Bonaparte" after one day earlier accusing Moscow of
"Kremlin (business) Capers" and admonishing investors
against "putting money into Russia." On the 12th, it
warned that "Georgia is only the first stop for
Eurasia's new imperialist." It referred to Putin
"consolidat(ing) his authoritarian transition as Prime
Minister with a figurehead president....Ukraine is in
his sights, and even the Balkan states could be
threatened if he's allowed to get away with it. The
West needs to draw a line at Georgia."
It called on NATO to "respond forcefully....start
today (and said) this is perhaps the last chance for
President Bush to salvage any kind of positive legacy
toward Russia (by) rally(ing) the West's response."
Putin seeks to "dominat(e)....the world stage. Unless
Russians see that there are costs for their Napoleon's
expansionism, Georgia isn't likely to be his last
stop."
Welcome to the new Cold War and new Great Game, what a
new administration will inherit next year, and the
very worrisome thought that it will handle things no
better than the current one no matter who's elected or
which party controls Congress.
Stephen Lendman is a Research Associate of the Centre
for Research on Globalization. He lives in Chicago and
can be reached at lendmanstephen@sbcglobal.net.
Also visit his blog site at sjlendman.blogspot.com and
listen to The Global Research News Hour on
RepublicBroadcasting.org Mondays from 11AM - 1PM US
Behind the War between Georgia and South Ossetia
|